Can vaping help you quit smoking?


Tash Barlow began smoking when she was 16.

Six years later, she was on 20 cigarettes a day, and had already tried the favored give up strategies.

“We did the patches, we did the gum, we did Champix, we tried all the things and none of it labored,” the Darwin native explains.

Tash and her husband Dylan determined to attempt vaping as they needed to have a child and had been feeling the opposite results of smoking, discovering themselves so out of breath they could not sustain with their canines on a stroll.

“As quickly as I picked up the vape, I did not want cigarettes anymore. We had been utilizing nicotine in our juice and we simply step by step minimize down on that as nicely.”

Tash now vapes with virtually no nicotine and is assured she will give up vaping altogether quickly.

Dr Jamie Hartmann-Boyce is the lead creator of the Cochrane assessment into e-cigarettes and quitting smoking, which is a scientific assessment utilizing the outcomes of research that meet sure high quality standards. She’s been engaged on the assessment since 2014 and her workforce analyses new proof month-to-month to maintain their findings updated.

Dr Hartmann-Boyce says whereas vaping will help, it is vital to recollect there is not any “magic bullet” for quitting, as smoking is so uniquely addictive.

Even in essentially the most extensively identified give up strategies, like nicotine patches, she says nearly all of trial individuals do not give up smoking.

Dr Hartmann-Boyce explains how most individuals try and give up a number of occasions, utilizing totally different strategies, which could work for them however not for others. So do you have to think about vaping?

Different strategies have extra proof behind them

Dr Hartmann-Boyce says up to now, her workforce has discovered “average certainty proof” that nicotine e-cigarettes are simpler than nicotine substitute therapies like patches or gum.

The proof is barely ‘reasonably sure’ as her workforce would not but have sufficient proof to assessment.

For those who’re after a give up methodology with “excessive certainty proof”, Dr Hartmann-Boyce recommends a course of the prescription treatment varenicline (which is offered in Australia beneath the model title Champix) mixed with behavioural assist.

Nonetheless, she says that varenicline’s unwanted side effects can put folks off, one thing Tash skilled.

“Champix simply made us really feel actually sick, however we had been nonetheless smoking which made it even worse.”

NPS MedicineWise advises widespread unwanted side effects embrace nausea, insomnia, irregular desires, complications and constipation. There’s additionally a danger of significant adversarial psychiatric results and a small elevated danger of cardiovascular (coronary heart) occasions, with not less than one demise in Australia linked to the drug.

For Tamra Smith, from Parramatta in Sydney’s west, Champix and a give up smoking app was the successful mixture.

She went from smoking 15 cigarettes a day, for 30 years, to fully quitting in September 2020.

Tamra give up after smoking for 30 years, and finds monitoring the cash she’s saving a useful motivator. (



Whereas she tried vaping to give up, it did not work for her.

“I discovered myself dashing dwelling to have a cigarette after work.

“It took the sting off the nicotine craving however I nonetheless needed to have a cigarette, as a result of it is that flavour, it is the throat feeling, it is the entire act of getting a cigarette. Though you suppose vaping is identical, it is simply not.”

Tamra did not really feel any unwanted side effects with varenicline, although she says it turned her husband into “the indignant man from hell”.

She says utilizing an app to trace how a lot cash she was saving helped together with her motivation, and as soon as she reached $1,000 she made certain to deal with herself.

Whereas she nonetheless has “a cheeky cigarette right here and there”, she says these days “it tastes like butt”.

Vaping can replicate smoking habits

Whereas Tamra did not discover vaping akin to an actual cigarette, the similarities between the 2 merchandise do the trick for some.

“There’s two components to smoking dependancy,” explains Colin Mendelsohn, founding chairman of the Australian Tobacco Hurt Discount Affiliation.

“One is the organic dependancy to nicotine, and nicotine substitute therapies and Champix assist with that.

“However the different vital a part of the dependancy is the behavior, the behavioural side of smoking, the hand-to-mouth motion, the sensations, the style. That is all a part of a conditioned response, so individuals are hooked on that.”

Dr Mendelsohn says when mixed with nicotine, vaping’s behavioural similarities to smoking will help folks give up.

Vaping can recreate the sensation of getting a cigarette.(

ABC Information: Jedda Costa


For Tash, vaping hit the “feeling” of getting a cigarette that patches and gum could not examine to.

“The factor with smoking is that you simply get into a really particular routine, so I’d at all times have a cigarette with my espresso, earlier than mattress, after meals. And I used to be lacking that.

“I could not simply have my espresso with a nicotine patch — it is not the identical feeling.”

Public well being issues about vaping

In Australia, it is unlawful to purchase or promote nicotine to be used in e-cigarettes, so most individuals buy it on-line from nations like New Zealand. Most states additionally ban the possession of liquid nicotine with no prescription.

From October 2021, it’s going to even be unlawful to import nicotine from abroad with no prescription.

The TGA says this is because of public well being issues, in addition to the danger of non-smoking younger folks taking on smoking in future.

Dr Gary Chan, senior analysis fellow on the Nationwide Centre for Youth Substance Use Analysis, says it is vital to handle these issues.

“We do not wish to promote vaping amongst younger folks … it truly would not matter whether or not vaping will result in smoking, this isn’t an excellent factor. We do not wish to see our children getting hooked on nicotine.”

He says whereas vaping is much less dangerous than smoking, it is not innocent, and the suitable insurance policies must be in place to stop uptake in non-smokers.

However given his latest analysis has demonstrated how vaping will help folks give up smoking, which has killed over 20,000 Australians in a yr, he says insurance policies that encourage people who smoke to modify “may very well be an incredible achieve in public well being”.

For Dr Hartmann-Boyce, issues round e-cigarettes rely in your priorities.

“It relies upon should you view the issue as dependancy or if the issue is the hurt brought on by that dependancy,” she explains.

“We all know that e-cigarettes aren’t fully secure, however we additionally know that they are significantly much less dangerous than common cigarettes.

“So if we’re speaking about individuals who smoke, switching to e-cigarettes, they’re decreasing hurt even when they’re staying hooked on nicotine.

However she says if individuals who do not smoke turn out to be hooked on cigarettes, they’re “probably rising hurt”.

For those who’ve by no means tried to give up earlier than, Dr Hartmann-Boyce recommends speaking to a quit smoking specialist and getting a prescription for mixture nicotine substitute remedy or varenicline.

However in case you have already tried these strategies, or are cautious about varenicline’s unwanted side effects, she says “attempting to give up utilizing nicotine e-cigarettes positively is proven to spice up success charges within the research we have checked out”.

Tamra says that no matter methodology you utilize “it’s a must to really need it”.

“It’s a must to be fully fed up with it and it’s a must to get that proper mixture at the moment. That is why they are saying hold attempting. As a result of finally you will hit that candy spot and give up and achieve success.”

ABC On a regular basis in your inbox

Get our publication for one of the best of ABC On a regular basis every week

Like it? Share with your friends!



Your email address will not be published.